Jessica DeMay

The Original Sicilian Pizza Dough Recipe

The Sicilian Sfincione is the pizza every Italian Nonna (grandmother) loves to make because it's so simple to make yet delicious.

True Sicilian Pizza, or sfincione, has a thick crust, similar in texture to focaccia, that is soft in the middle but crispy and golden on the bottom. This type of pizza originated in Sicily, Italy, hence its name. 

Sicilian Pizza Dough

This recipe will show you how to make traditional sicilian pizza.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 1 d 2 hrs
Cook Time 15 mins
Course Pizza
Cuisine Italian

Ingredients
  

  • 500 g Tipo 00 flour
  • 10 g Fine sea salt
  • 3 tbsp Extra virgin olive oil
  • 10 g Fresh yeast
  • 300 g Lukewarm water
  • A pinch of sugar

Instructions
 

  • Mix flour, yeast, salt, olive oil, and a pinch of sugar with the water and create a homogenous mixture.
  • Place the dough in an airtight container and refrigerate it for at least 24 hours.
  • Cover the bottom and edges of a half-sheet pan with olive oil.
  • Transfer the dough to the pan and stretch it with your hands. Allow the dough to relax, uncovered, for about 10 to 15 minutes, then stretch it again.
  • Let the dough rise in the pan for at least an hour before you add the toppings. Toppings consist of tomato sauce, grated Caciocavallo cheese, breadcrumbs, and optionally pepperoni.

History of Sicilian Pizza

The sfincione originated in Palermo and differs from Neapolitan pizza in that it is usually rectangular and consists of more dough, sauce, and cheese. The shape comes from the baking pans needed to cook the crust. While there are many variations of Sicilian pizza, the original recipe usually calls for onion, tomato sauce, cheese, and anchovies. In some preparations, the tomato sauce is added on top of the toppings so that it doesn’t soak into the dough. 

When sfincione was introduced in the United States by Sicilian immigrants, “Sicilian pizza” became the way to describe a type of square pizza that has dough over an inch thick. Like the original sfincione, the crust of the Americanized version was very light and airy on the inside and crispy on the bottom. 

Sicilian Pizza Toppings

Following the original recipe first used in Sicily, an authentic Sicilian pizza calls for a meatless sauce, anchovies, onions, tomatoes, and herbs. Bread crumbs are then sprinkled over the toppings before a hard cheese is grated over the pizza to finish. The traditional recipe uses a lot of sauce and herbs to create an abundance of flavor without piling on additional toppings. 

It wasn’t until Sicilian pizza reached the United States that mozzarella was used to top the signature dough. Traditional Sicilian-style pizza doesn’t use mozzarella because it wasn’t an option on an island where cow’s milk isn’t available. Sicilian-style pizza in America also uses a larger variety of toppings, including pepperoni and mushrooms. 

Sicilian-Style Pizza vs Pan-Style Pizza

Many pizzerias in the United States offer “pan-style” pizzas that have a thick crust. Although the thickness of the crust is similar to that of a Sicilian-style pizza, they aren’t the same. 

The difference between Sicilian-style pizza and pan-style pizza is the edge of the crust. On a Sicilian pizza, the sauce and ingredients go right to the edge of the dough, leaving very little, if any, bordered crust. 

Why We Love Sicilian Pizza

There are many reasons to love Sicilian pizza, but the crust is the undeniable star of this dish. A traditional Sicilian-style pizza is baked in a pan that has been coated with olive oil. This mimics the act of “frying” the dough and creates the crunchy, flavorful bottom that Sicilian pizza dough is known for. The crispy base also allows the crust to maintain its texture if any liquid from the sauce or ingredients seeps into the bread underneath.

Enjoy! And also make sure you check out our general pizza dough recipe that you can use for pretty much every pizza.

The most obvious difference is the shape: Sicilian pizza is rectangular and Neapolitan pizza is round. Sicilian pizza also has a much thicker crust.
The traditional approach to Sicilian pizza calls for meatless sauce, herbs, and hard cheese such as caciocavalla. Some versions don’t include cheese, while many versions are topped with anchovies, onions, and tomatoes.
For the most authentic Sicilian pizza dough, you want to Tipo 00 flour. Tipo 00 flour is finely ground Italian pizza flour that makes a significant difference in the texture of your baked pizza crust.
Jessica DeMay
Jessica is the lead content creator of Dishcrawl. She has lived in Italy (Napoli) for 7 years and has since become absolutely obsessed with pizza.
© 2021 Dishcrawl. All rights reserved.
Dishcrawl participates in various affiliate programs, which means we may get paid commissions on certain products purchased through our links to retailer sites.
TwitterPinterestInstagram
crossmenu